Getting Ethical Approval for your PhD Research Project: Three key questions to ask

In the vast landscape of academic research, ethical considerations serve as the guiding stars that illuminate our path. Drawing from my extensive experience in UK universities, I invite you to join me on a reflective journey into the heart of research ethics. Let's explore the essence of ethical principles through three fundamental questions that shape the ethical compass of our research endeavors.

Question 1: Have We Anticipated Participant Emotions?

The foundation of ethical research lies in our ability to empathize and anticipate the emotional impact on our participants. It goes beyond the procedural checklist and delves into the realm of human experience. Imagine embarking on a study addressing a sensitive topic — how might participants feel about sharing their experiences and thoughts?

Putting ourselves in their shoes is not merely a theoretical exercise; it's a genuine attempt to understand their worries, concerns, and hesitations. If you were confronted with a study exploring a topic you find fundamentally embarrassing or shameful, what questions would race through your mind? Applying this empathetic lens allows us to craft research processes that respect and safeguard the emotional well-being of those who entrust us with their stories.

Question 2: Is Our Research Respectful?

Respect forms the bedrock of ethical research practices. It encompasses not only obtaining consent but also adopting an approach that values participants and their experiences. The second key question prompts us to evaluate the respect embedded in our research methodologies.

Consider practices that could be perceived as disrespectful — invasive data collection, trivializing experiences, or neglecting cultural sensitivity. Ethical research demands an acute awareness of the potential impacts of our actions. By actively engaging with communities, setting up advisory groups, and comprehending the rights and wishes of our participants, we cultivate an environment where research is a collaborative endeavor built on mutual respect.

Respect also extends to the language we use in our communications and materials. Ensuring accessibility and relatability in our communication fosters understanding and trust. When participants feel respected and valued, it not only enhances the quality of the research but also contributes to the overall ethical integrity of the project.

Question 3: Are We Researching With People?

The power dynamic between researchers and participants is a critical aspect often overlooked. Shifting from a mindset of doing research "to" people to one of researching "with" them signifies a move towards collaboration, participation, and co-production. The third key question urges us to reflect on this power dynamic and the implications it holds for the ethical integrity of our research.

Participants should feel empowered to withdraw from a study at any point without fear of judgment or negative consequences. Emphasizing this right in accessible language builds trust and ensures a more equal and ethical relationship. This not only aligns with the principles of respect but also contributes to the overall transparency and authenticity of the research process.

Crafting Ethical Research Materials:

The application of these three key questions extends beyond theoretical reflection into the practical aspects of research materials. From recruitment strategies to dissemination content, the language employed should mirror our commitment to ethical standards.

Every piece of communication — be it a participant information leaflet, consent form, or dissemination material — should uphold the principles of empathy, respect, and collaborative engagement. By consistently integrating these considerations into our research materials, we not only ensure ethical integrity but also contribute to a positive and trusting environment for all involved.

In conclusion, ethical research is not a checklist but a dynamic and evolving process shaped by our commitment to understanding, respect, and collaboration. By continually revisiting these three fundamental questions, we strengthen the ethical foundation of our research endeavors, fostering an environment where participants are not subjects but valued partners in the pursuit of knowledge. Let these questions guide your research, and together, let's navigate the ethical compass that leads us to responsible and impactful academic exploration.

Need step-by-step help with your PhD?

Check out my range of PhD Survival Guides! Click here to take a look.